Every curriculum vitae is a work of fiction by . It lists the degrees obtained, the posts held and the prizes won, but it says nothing of the applications rejected, the projects abandoned or the exams failed. A few years ago, a professor at Princeton University published what he called a "CV of failures", listing the programmes that had turned him down, the journals that had rejected his papers and the he had not received. It was shared far more widely than anything else he had written.
The reaction was . Readers were struck not by the failures themselves, which were entirely ordinary, but by the fact that someone had admitted to them in public. We are to a curated narrative of achievement in which appear, if at all, only as dramatic to eventual triumph. The struggling novelist rejected by twelve publishers is remembered because the thirteenth said yes. We hear far less about the many writers whose thirteenth attempt also failed.
This selective storytelling has consequences. If failure is invisible, it comes to seem abnormal, a private shame rather than an inevitable part of any ambitious undertaking. Students who have never been allowed to fail may find their first serious setback precisely because they have no experience of recovering from one. The psychologist Carol Dweck's research on mindset, though its practical applications have been at times, captures something important: people who interpret failure as information rather than as a on their worth are more likely to persist and, ultimately, to improve.
It would be , however, to romanticise failure. Not every setback is instructive; some are simply painful, and some are the product of circumstances, poverty, discrimination or sheer bad luck, that no amount of resilience can overcome. The fashionable to "fail fast, fail often", borrowed from technology start-ups, is easy advice for those who can afford to lose. For many people, a single failure carries costs that cannot be shrugged off as a learning opportunity.
What we might reasonably aim for, then, is not a celebration of failure but a more honest relationship with it: an acknowledgement that it is common, that it is rarely final, and that the capacity to examine it without is a skill that can be cultivated. A culture in which people could speak of their failures as readily as their successes would not be a culture of lowered standards. It might simply be one in which more people are willing to attempt difficult things.