In a footnote to his 1945 book The Open Society and Its Enemies, the philosopher Karl Popper an argument that has since taken on a life of its own. "Unlimited tolerance," he wrote, "must lead to the disappearance of tolerance." If a society extends tolerance without limit even to those who are intolerant, and is not prepared to defend itself against their , then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.
The "paradox of tolerance", as it has come to be known, is often quoted today in debates about free speech, usually as a justification for restricting extremist views. What is less often quoted is the that immediately follows. Popper did not suggest that intolerant philosophies should always be . As long as they can be countered by rational argument and by public opinion, he wrote, suppression would be "most unwise". The right to suppress them, by force if necessary, arises only when their refuse to engage in argument, forbid their followers to listen to it and "teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols".
This distinction, between ideas that are offensive and movements that seek to abolish the conditions of open debate itself, is crucial, and it is frequently lost. In its popular form, the paradox can be to justify silencing almost any view that one considers harmful, which risks turning a defence of the open society into a for the very intolerance it was meant to guard against. Who decides which views are intolerant? The history of censorship suggests that such power, once granted, is rarely to its original targets.
Some philosophers have proposed reframing the question altogether. Tolerance, they argue, is better understood not as a moral principle to be applied universally but as a kind of peace treaty: an agreement among people with deeply different beliefs to coexist without . Those who reject the treaty, who seek to impose their views by force or to deny others the same freedoms, place themselves outside its protection. On this view, refusing to tolerate the intolerant is not a contradiction but simply the enforcement of the treaty's terms.
None of these formulations resolves every hard case. Where precisely does disagreement end and the destruction of open debate begin? Reasonable people will draw that line in different places, and the line itself shifts with technology, as social media amplifies voices and accelerates the spread of both argument and . What Popper's careful footnote offers is not a formula but a discipline: a reminder that the defence of open societies requires both firmness against those who would destroy them and in deciding who they are.