It has become an in affluent societies that choice is an good. The more options we have, the reasoning goes, the more likely we are to find precisely what suits us, and the freer we are to shape our lives according to our own preferences. Supermarkets stock dozens of varieties of olive oil; streaming services offer more films than anyone could watch in a lifetime; dating apps present a seemingly supply of potential partners. Who could object to that?
A growing number of psychologists, as it happens. In a now-famous experiment conducted in an Californian grocery store, researchers set up a tasting stand offering either six or twenty-four varieties of jam. The larger display attracted more attention, but shoppers who encountered the smaller selection were roughly ten times more likely to actually buy a jar. Faced with too many alternatives, people, it seemed, simply the decision altogether. Although subsequent attempts to the finding have produced mixed results, the study an intuition that many had long .
The psychologist Barry Schwartz has argued that an overabundance of choice in subtler ways too. When options are few, a disappointing outcome can be attributed to the world; when they are virtually unlimited, it can only be attributed to oneself. Every choice carries the shadow of the alternatives , and the more numerous those alternatives, the larger the shadow. Schwartz distinguishes between "maximisers", who feel compelled to examine every option in pursuit of the best, and "satisficers", who settle for the first option that meets their criteria. Paradoxically, maximisers often achieve objectively better outcomes, a higher starting salary, say, yet report feeling less satisfied with them.
None of this amounts to an argument for . For much of human history, and for a great many people today, the problem has been too little choice rather than too much, and the freedom to decide where to live, whom to marry and what to believe is hardly a trivial luxury. The point is rather that the relationship between choice and well-being is not linear. Beyond a certain , additional options cease to liberate and begin to burden.
Perhaps the most practical lesson is that we can impose constraints on ourselves where the world declines to. Deciding in advance to consider only three options, adopting the habits of a satisficer in matters that are genuinely unimportant, or simply resolving not to revisit a decision once it is made: such self-imposed limits may seem like a of freedom. In practice, they may be what allows us to enjoy it.