In medical research, the placebo has traditionally been treated as a . When a new drug is tested, some patients receive the real medication while others are given an identical-looking pill containing nothing but sugar. If the drug performs no better than the pill, it is considered . The placebo, in other words, exists to be beaten.
Increasingly, however, researchers have become fascinated by the placebo , because its effects can be remarkably powerful. In trials for conditions ranging from chronic back pain to irritable bowel syndrome and depression, a proportion of patients taking placebos report significant improvements. These are not merely imagined: brain scans have shown that placebo painkillers can the release of the body's own natural pain-relieving chemicals.
The effect appears to be shaped by context and expectation in ways that are sometimes surprising. Studies have found that two placebo pills tend to work better than one, that capsules are often more effective than tablets, and that a placebo described as expensive can an identical one described as cheap. Even the colour of the pill seems to matter, with blue pills more likely to be associated with calming effects and red ones with stimulating effects. The manner of the doctor plays a role too: patients treated with warmth and attention tend to respond better than those treated .
Perhaps the most finding comes from research into so-called "open-label" placebos. In several studies, patients were told plainly that they were receiving sugar pills with no active ingredients, yet many of them still reported feeling better than those who received no treatment at all. Some researchers suggest that the ritual of taking a pill, combined with the belief that the body can heal itself, may be enough to activate genuine responses.
This raises awkward ethical questions. Deliberately patients is generally regarded as incompatible with modern medicine, which places great value on honesty and . Open-label placebos might offer a way around this , though few doctors would recommend them as a substitute for proven treatments for serious illnesses. What the placebo effect does reveal, unmistakably, is that the boundary between mind and body is far less than we once assumed.