In 1999, the centre of Pontevedra, a small city in north-west Spain, was a typical example of twentieth-century urban planning. Its narrow medieval streets were with traffic, the air was polluted and the historic squares had become car parks. Many residents had moved out to the . That year, a newly elected mayor took a decision that was widely considered politically : he banned private cars from the old town almost entirely.
Two decades later, the results are hard to argue with. Traffic-related carbon emissions have fallen dramatically, and for years the city recorded no traffic deaths at all. and children have reclaimed the streets, and small shops, which opponents predicted would collapse without passing car trade, have in many cases . Perhaps most tellingly, the population of the centre, which had been shrinking, has grown.
Pontevedra is not an case. Across Europe and beyond, cities are rethinking the space they have to cars. Oslo has removed most parking spaces from its city centre and replaced them with benches, bicycle lanes and small parks. Paris has turned stretches of the busy roads along the Seine into pedestrian and is promoting the concept of the "fifteen-minute city", in which residents can reach most of their daily needs, from schools to shops to doctors, within a short walk or bike ride.
Such changes rarely come without resistance. Business owners frequently fear losing customers, and residents of outlying areas complain that they are being for living far from public transport. Critics also warn that car-free centres risk becoming playgrounds for the , pushing up property prices and forcing poorer residents to move further out. counter that cars themselves impose enormous hidden costs on cities, in the form of pollution, noise, accidents and land that could be used for housing or green space.
What these experiments suggest is that the dominance of the car in urban life is not but the result of choices, choices that can be revisited. As the former mayor of Pontevedra once put it, "Owning a car doesn't give you the right to occupy public space." Whether other cities are willing to follow his example may depend less on engineering than on political courage.