The street on which I grew up no longer exists. Not in the poetic sense in which all childhood streets are lost to those who leave them, but literally: the low houses with their vine-covered were fifteen years ago to make way for a residential complex of grey towers, and even the curve of the road was straightened. When I returned for the first time, I stood on what must have been the spot where our front door had been and felt nothing at all, which was more than grief would have been.
Orhan Pamuk has written that the of Istanbul, its hüzün, is in part a collective response to living among the ruins of a vanished . Yet the kind of loss I am describing is more ordinary and more widespread. In rapidly changing cities everywhere, people find that the physical of their personal histories have been erased: the cinema where they had their first date, the school playground, the corner shop whose owner knew their name. The city continues, often more and more efficient than before, but it has ceased to be their city.
Psychologists have long known that memory is closely bound to place. We remember better in the setting where we first learned something, and returning to a familiar environment can trigger we did not know we retained. Philosophers of place have gone further, arguing that our sense of identity is partly by the places we inhabit, that we do not simply live in places but are, in some measure, made by them. If this is so, then the destruction of a familiar landscape is not merely an aesthetic or economic event but an injury to the self.
It would be , however, to resist all change in the name of memory. Cities that do not change decay; the houses of my childhood were damp, cold in winter and vulnerable to earthquakes, and many of the families who lived in them were glad to leave. Nostalgia is selective, preserving the warmth of the courtyard and forgetting the leaking roof. The question is not whether cities should change, but how, and whether the people who live in them have any say in what is kept.
Some cities have experimented with ways of preserving memory without freezing the : retaining fragments of old buildings within new ones, naming streets and squares after what once stood there, or collecting the oral histories of residents before redevelopment begins. These gestures cannot restore what is lost. But they acknowledge something that pure efficiency overlooks: that a city is not only a machine for living but also an archive of lives, and that a place entirely of its memories can leave its inhabitants strangely homeless, even in the street where they were born.