For most of human history, memory was considered a kind of : experiences were recorded, stored and, with varying degrees of success, . Over the past few decades, neuroscience has this picture. Memories, it turns out, are not fixed recordings but . Each time we recall an event, the memory becomes briefly unstable before being stored again, a process known as . During that window, it can be strengthened, weakened or subtly altered.
This discovery has opened up remarkable possibilities. In experimental studies, patients with post-traumatic stress disorder who were given certain drugs while recalling a traumatic event later reported that the memory had lost some of its emotional . They had not forgotten what happened; rather, the recollection no longer triggered the same overwhelming fear. For people whose lives have been by trauma, the prospect is undeniably attractive.
Yet the possibility of deliberately editing memory raises questions that go well beyond the clinic. If a drug could soften the pain of grief, should it be offered to anyone who has lost a loved one? Grief is , but it is also, many would argue, an expression of love, and a process through which we come to terms with loss. To erase its sting might be to diminish the very relationship it . Similarly, painful memories of our own failures and wrongdoings may be precisely what enables us to learn, to apologise and to change.
There are social dimensions too. Memory is not only personal but collective. Societies remember wars, injustices and disasters, and these memories, however painful, shape their moral commitments. A soldier who could dull his memory of an he witnessed might be spared years of suffering, but he might also become a less reliable witness. One can imagine pressures, legal, commercial or political, to memories that are inconvenient to others.
None of this constitutes a decisive argument against memory-modifying treatments, any more than the potential for misuse constitutes an argument against painkillers. What it suggests is that the line between healing and erasing deserves careful . The aim of such therapies, perhaps, should not be to make us forget, but to make it possible to remember without being destroyed by remembering. Whether that distinction can be maintained in practice is a question that science alone cannot answer.