Few topics divide parents, students and teachers quite like homework. Some schools in Europe and North America have experimented with it altogether, particularly for younger children, while others that it is essential for academic success. We asked two experienced teachers to .
Against homework, Ms. Aydın, primary school teacher: "After a six-hour school day, children need time to play, rest, see their families and their own interests. Research has found little evidence that homework improves results in primary school, and too much of it is linked to stress, sleep problems and a negative attitude towards learning. Homework also deepens . A child with educated parents and a quiet room at home has a huge advantage over a child who shares a small flat with four . If we want children to practise something, we should give them time to do it at school, where everyone has the same support."
For homework, Mr. Kılıç, secondary school teacher: "I agree that young children should not be . But for teenagers, the evidence is different: studies suggest that amounts of homework are associated with better results in secondary school. Homework teaches skills that cannot be learned in a classroom: managing your own time, working and taking responsibility. Learning a language or mathematics requires regular practice, and there simply isn't enough time in a forty-minute lesson. The answer to bad homework is not no homework; it's better homework."
Interestingly, both teachers agreed on several points. Homework should be meaningful rather than , such as copying answers or colouring in. It should be short enough to finish without help from parents. And teachers should give on it; homework that is collected and never discussed teaches students only that it doesn't matter.
Perhaps the real question is not whether homework should exist, but what kind of homework is worth a child's time. Reading for pleasure, preparing questions for the next lesson, interviewing a grandparent or practising a skill for fifteen minutes a day may achieve more than hours of worksheets.