Non-defining Relative Clauses
A comma clause is extra; the sentence still makes sense without it
A non-defining clause adds extra information about a person or thing and sits between two commas: My brother, who lives in Ankara, is a doctor. Without it the sentence still works. Use who (people), which (things), whose (possession), where (places). that is not used; who / which can't be dropped.
A defining clause has no commas and identifies who or which one: The man who called is my uncle. which can also refer to a whole clause: He passed, which surprised me.
Defining or non-defining?
Turkish participle clauses (Ankara'da yaşayan kardeşim) work for both identifying and extra information. English sets extra information off with commas and can't use that. Commas change meaning: My brother who lives in Ankara (I have several brothers), My brother, who lives in Ankara (I have one brother). For the basics see Relative Clauses.
The patterns side by side
3 small traps · Tap to see the fix
✗My brother, that lives…
✗The film which I saw , was…
✗Ali, who's car…
Choose the word
Pick the word or form that fits the gap.
Which one fits?
Pick the right option. Every correct answer helps your progress.
Match the sentence halves
Pick a half on the left, then find its partner on the right.
Find and fix the mistake
Fix the mistake in the underlined part.
You finished everything! 🎉
For teachers
- Write a family introduction. Students add extra information with My sister, who…
- Show the meaning of commas. Compare My brother who… and My brother, who…
- Find newspaper examples. Mark non-defining clauses.
- Project the Mistakes tab. Have the class find the errors before showing the corrections.
- Do the “Type it” level with books closed. With no options, students must build the form themselves.