Skip to content
Mr. Şeker
Türkçe
Interactive Grammar Station · Students

Non-defining Relative Clauses

PROGRESS0 / 40 (0%)
00

A comma clause is extra; the sentence still makes sense without it

Pick an example:
▶ Press Play
EXTRA INFORMATIONSET OFF BY COMMAS ➕

A non-defining clause adds extra information about a person or thing and sits between two commas: My brother, who lives in Ankara, is a doctor. Without it the sentence still works. Use who (people), which (things), whose (possession), where (places). that is not used; who / which can't be dropped.

, who / which / whose / where + clause,
🔑 My sister, who lives in Izmir, is a nurse.
VS DEFININGCOMMAS = EXTRA 🔍

A defining clause has no commas and identifies who or which one: The man who called is my uncle. which can also refer to a whole clause: He passed, which surprised me.

defining: no commas · non-defining: commas
🔑 The man who called · Ali, who called,

Defining or non-defining?

virgüllüextra informationAli, who is tall, plays.
virgülsüzidentifying informationThe man who called…
who / which / whose / wherecan be usedIzmir, where I live,
thatnot after a comma✗ Ali, that is tall
which + cümlerefers to the whole clauseHe passed, which surprised me.
nesne atılmazwho / which stayThe film, which I saw,

Turkish participle clauses (Ankara'da yaşayan kardeşim) work for both identifying and extra information. English sets extra information off with commas and can't use that. Commas change meaning: My brother who lives in Ankara (I have several brothers), My brother, who lives in Ankara (I have one brother). For the basics see Relative Clauses.

The patterns side by side

Personisim, who + fiil,Ali, who is tall,
Thingisim, which + cümle,the film, which I saw,
Possessionisim, whose + isim + fiil,Ali, whose car is red,
Placeyer, where + cümle,Izmir, where I live,
Whole clausecümle, which + fiilHe passed, which surprised me.
that✗ virgülden sonra kullanılmaz✗ Ali, that is tall

3 small traps · Tap to see the fix

✗My brother, that lives…
✓ My brother, who lives…
No that after a comma.
✗The film which I saw , was…
✓ The film, which I saw, was…
Two commas.
✗Ali, who's car…
✓ Ali, whose car…
whose.

For teachers

Topic order

Related pages

All your answers will be cleared. Are you sure?